Blog

Choosing health insurance is important. In Nigeria, many people choose between NHIS (National Health Insurance Scheme) and private health insurance (HMOs or private insurers). Each has benefits and drawbacks. For students, working class people, and families, knowing the difference helps you make a good decision—what is best for your health needs and budget.

What is NHIS and What is Private Health Insurance?

• NHIS stands for National Health Insurance Scheme, earlier act, now evolving under the National Health Insurance Authority (NHIA).

• It is a government‑led or public health insurance scheme. One aim is to reduce out‑of‑pocket payments for healthcare, improve access, and protect people against large medical bills.

• Created by law in 1999, became operational around 2005.

Definition of Private Health Insurance in Nigeria

• Private health insurance means plans provided by private companies or Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs). These are non‑government entities. Users pay premiums, and get services via hospitals/clinics in their private network.

• Private health insurance often provides more options, faster service, better amenities, and sometimes more specialized care—but tends to cost more.

How NHIS and Private Health Insurance Work in Nigeria

How NHIS Works

NHIS Programs and Who is Covered

• NHIS has several programmes: Formal Sector Social Health Insurance Programme (FSSHIP) for government employees and organized private sector; Informal Sector Social Health Insurance; Vulnerable Groups; students; community programmes.

• Contributions: for formal sector, both employers and employees contribute. For example, in some cases employer pays ~10% and employee ~5% of basic salary.

• The scheme aims to cover the insured person plus some dependents (spouse, children) under certain age conditions.

 How to Use NHIS Services

• You register under an NHIS program or scheme via your employer (if formal sector) or via voluntary/informal scheme if eligible. NHIS accredits hospitals/clinics; you use these approved ones for services. If facility is not accredited, coverage may be denied or reduced.

• For many medical services, there are set benefit packages. For example outpatient care, diagnostics, maternal care, medicines as per NHIS drug list.

Costs and Payment under NHIS

• Premium/contribution is often deducted from salary (for formal workers) — employer/employee contribution.

• Informal sector or voluntary contributors may pay premium directly. The amount depends on plan and level of coverage.

• NHIS aims to reduce out‑of‑pocket payments (OOP), but many people still pay something, especially for non‑covered items, or when using non‑accredited facilities.

How Private Health Insurance Works

Private Health Maintenance Organisations (HMOs)

• Private HMOs contract with hospitals/clinics. They negotiate tariffs, define network of providers.

• Members choose a plan (basic, premium, family, etc.), pay premium, then receive services from network providers.

Service Features of Private Plans

• More flexibility: you might choose hospital, doctor, facility, possibly private ward.

• Often faster service, shorter waiting times, better amenities.

• Additional services may be included: specialist consultations, dental, optical, wellness, elective surgeries, high‑end diagnostics.

Cost Structure of Private Insurance

• Premiums tend to be higher. The more features you want (hospital network, specialist access, better amenities), the higher the premium.

• There may be co‑payments, deductibles, extra for out‑of‑network services.

• Private plans may also have waiting periods for some services.

What Do They Cover: NHIS vs Private Health Insurance

Coverage Comparison of Services

Geographic, Network & Facility Quality Differences

• NHIS works with approved hospitals/clinics; sometimes mostly public hospitals and general/teaching hospitals. In rural areas, network may be sparse.

• Private health insurance tends to have hospitals/clinics that are private, often in urban areas; more choice; possibly better amenities, shorter queues.

• If your location is rural, NHIS might be more accessible (if there is an approved hospital), private may have fewer options or require travel.

Costs: Price, Premiums, Out‑of‑Pocket & Hidden Fees

How Much Does NHIS Cost vs Private Insurance

• NHIS contributions for formal sector: employer/employee splits; for informal sector or voluntary contributors, fixed premiums. Generally designed to be more affordable for lower income.

• Private insurance plans have a range: basic plans cheaper, premium plans much more expensive. The cost depends on hospital network, coverage, amenities.

Out‑of‑Pocket Payments & Hidden Costs

• Even with NHIS, users may pay some portion for services not covered (non‑listed medicines, premium amenities, other extra charges).

• Private insurance may have deductible or co‑payment schedules (you pay a portion of the cost), especially for high level services or out‑of‑network.

• Travel costs to approved facilities, times waiting for approvals, paperwork can add cost (time & money).

Speed, Service Quality & Waiting Times

• NHIS sometimes slower due to bureaucracy, higher patient volume, public hospital settings.

• Private insurers often have faster authorisation, shorter waiting times, better customer support, possibly better equipment and amenities.

Pros and Cons: NHIS vs Private Health Insurance

Pros of NHIS

1. Affordability / Lower Premiums for many people, especially formal workers under employer contributions and for vulnerable groups.

2. Basic Health Coverage: NHIS covers many essential health services like outpatient, maternity, medicines, diagnostics.

3. Risk Pooling: By pooling many persons (formal and informal sectors), risk is spread.

4. Government Regulation and Oversight: Standards, regulation, law backing (NHIA Act 2022).

5. Inclusion of Vulnerable Groups: Programs for children <5, pregnant women, informal sector, vulnerable populations.

Cons of NHIS

1. Limited Coverage Options: Some services, specialist care, high‑cost diagnostics, brand name drugs may not be included.

2. Service Delays / Bureaucracy: Longer waiting times, delays in authorisation or service.

3. Facility Constraints: Public or general hospitals often have limited comfort, amenities; quality varies.

4. Low Uptake & Limited Reach: Many Nigerians are not enrolled; rural and informal sectors less covered.

5. Hidden Costs: For non‑accredited institutions, non‑listed drugs, extras not covered.

Advantages of Private Health Insurance

1. More Choice: Hospitals, specialists, amenities, quality of service; private hospital options.

2. Faster Service: Often shorter queues, quicker authorizations, better customer service.

3. Flexible Cover: Ability to get more extensive diagnostics, certain elective procedures, better medicines.

4. Better Comfort / Amenities: Private wards, nicer rooms, maybe better facilities.

5. More Innovation / Extras: Telemedicine, wellness programs, preventative screening, health monitoring apps etc.

Pros of Private Health Insurance

1. Cost: Premiums are higher; may be unaffordable for many working class or low income people.

2. Exclusions & Waiting Periods: Some plans exclude pre‑existing conditions, high risk, or have waiting periods for certain services.

3. Network Restrictions: If hospital is not in the insurer’s network, you may pay more or full cost.

4. Complexity: More paperwork sometimes, more conditions, claims processes more complex.

5. Risk of Over‑Insurance: Paying for features you seldom use.

Key Differences Between NHIS and Private Health Insurance in Nigeria

Here is a direct look at the major contrasts between the two systems in way that helps you decide which is better for your situation.

Governance and Regulation

• NHIS (or NHIA) is governed by law; mandatory reforms, regulator oversight. The new NHIA Act (2022) made insurance more regulated.

• Private insurers are regulated too, but their plans are determined by competition, commercial viability, and customer preferences.

Financing and Payment Structures

• NHIS uses pooled funds; contributions may be via salary deduction (employer/employee), government subsidies for vulnerable, and some mandatory components under law.

• Private insurance financing is via premium paid by individual/family; risk assessed; price depends on level of coverage.

Eligibility and Enrollment

• NHIS originally focused on formal sector employees, but includes informal sector, voluntary contributors, vulnerable groups. Some limitations in who must contribute.

• Private insurance is voluntary; anyone who can afford and whose plan accepts them can join.

Benefit Packages and Coverage Levels

• NHIS has a prescribed benefit package; some limitations; emphasis on common illnesses, maternity, basic diagnostics.

• Private insurers offer tiers: basic to premium; optional add‑ons; more flexibility in what is covered.

Quality, Speed, Comfort, Customer Service Differences

• Private insurers usually deliver faster, more comfortable service. NHIS sometimes uses public hospitals with more congestion.

• Private may have better amenities; NHIS may be in hospitals with more patients and fewer comforts.

 Geographic Reach and Access

• NHIS has public reach; more government facilities; aims to cover rural areas via community‑based programmes. But actual access in rural may be limited.

• Private insurers are usually more prevalent in urban areas; private hospitals/clinics commonly in cities.

Cost to the Individual Over Time

• NHIS tends to reduce the cost burden for individuals, especially for predictable medical needs, maternal care, diagnosis, etc. Over time, less out‑of‑pocket.

• Private insurance cost is higher, but for people who desire high quality, less waiting, and willing to pay for extras, it may be worth it.

Real‑Life Examples: Choosing NHIS or Private Health Insurance

Here are some stories that illustrate how different people may decide between NHIS and private insurance.

Example 1 – A Civil Servant Choosing NHIS

• Name: Chinedu works for a federal agency in Abuja.

• He is enrolled under NHIS formal sector. Employer deducts contributi­on. He has NHIS benefits: outpatient care, doctor visits, maternity, basic diagnostics.

• His hospital is public, sometimes crowded. He waits when many patients. But cost is low; he does not worry much about large medical bills.

• For specialist care or wanting better comfort (private ward), he sometimes pays out‑of‑pocket or uses private facility.

Example 2 – Private Sector Worker Wanting High Comfort

• Name: Aisha works in Lagos for a private company. She is willing to pay more to get premium care, private hospital, shorter wait times.

• She buys a private insurance plan through an HMO. She pays higher premium, but gets access to private hospital, specialist doctors, optional extras like dental, screening, etc.

• When she had an emergency, she was attended quickly; but she pays significantly more in premium and sometimes for brand medicines.

Example 3 – Family in Rural Area Considering both

• Name: The Okoro family lives in a semi‑rural area. Their nearest large private hospital is far. Public clinic is near but small.

• For them, NHIS is attractive because it includes local public clinics and reduces cost. But quality and speed may be less.

• They consider private insurance plan to cover some emergencies and specialist access in nearby town; but cost is a concern. They may choose a mid‑range private HMO plus NHIS to cover basics.

How to Decide Which Option Is Best for You

Here are steps and criteria to help you pick what fits your needs—NHIS, private insurance, or a mix.

First, Know Your Health Needs & Budget

• How often do you or your family need medical care?

• Do you need specialist consultations, high‑cost diagnostics, frequent drugs, maternity?

• How much can you afford for premium vs unexpected costs?

Evaluate Facility Access & Quality Nearby

• Are there NHIS‑approved hospitals/clinics near you? Are they good quality?

• Are there private hospitals in your area? Are they in the network of private insurers?

Compare Benefit Packages & Hidden Costs

• What exactly is covered in NHIS vs what private plan offers?

• For private, check if brand name drugs are covered, specialist services, hospital stay, luxury wards, dental/optical etc.

• Investigate waiting periods, exclusions.

Consider Long‑Term Value & Risk Protection

• Good insurance helps avoid catastrophic health bills later.

• If you expect future medical needs (pregnancy, chronic disease etc.), a better coverage plan may be worth paying more.

Try Hybrid or Supplementary Coverage

• Some people use NHIS for basic coverage and take private insurance for extra services.

• Private insurance may supplement NHIS limitations.

Summary Table: NHIS vs Private Health Insurance Comparison

Here is a summary table so you see at a glance the major differences. Useful when deciding which option suits you best.

Conclusion: Which One Should You Pick?

Both NHIS and private health insurance have a place in Nigeria’s healthcare landscape. Understanding the difference helps you make a smart choice. Here are concluding thoughts.

• If your priority is affordability, basic coverage and protection against common illnesses or maternity, NHIS is often very good.

• If you want fast service, better hospitals, more specialist care, comfort, then private insurance may be worth the extra cost.

• Many people choose a mix: use NHIS for base healthcare and get private insurance for extras.

• Always check what services you really need, what your budget can support, and what facilities are near you.

For working class citizens or students, NHIS may be enough. But if your needs are greater, private health insurance gives more options—but at cost.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What is the NHIA Act 2022 & how does it change NHIS?
   The NHIA Act (National Health Insurance Authority Act) replaced or expanded the previous scheme (NHIS) with stronger regulation. It made health insurance more mandatory, introduced new funds for vulnerable groups, and pushed state health insurance schemes.

2. Is private insurance always better than NHIS?
   Not always. Private insurance can offer more amenities, speed, and choice—but it costs more. For many people, NHIS gives enough protection. “Better” depends on your needs and budget.

3. Can someone use both NHIS and private health insurance?
   Yes. You can have NHIS coverage and also buy private insurance for services NHIS doesn’t cover (specialist care, premium amenities). But you cannot claim the same service twice.

4. How much does NHIS typically cost for formal sector workers?
   Formal sector workers usually have contributions split between employer and employee. For example, employer contribution might be around 10% and employee 5% of salary in some programmes. But actual cost may vary depending on salary, number of dependents, etc.

5. What about people in the informal sector—can they use NHIS?
   Yes. NHIS has programmes to cover informal sector, voluntary contributors, and vulnerable groups. They pay fixed premiums or contributions. But enrolment and reach may be less well developed.

6. What services does NHIS not cover that private insurance might?
   Private insurance may cover more specialized surgeries, higher‑end diagnostics (MRI, CT), private ward, more choice of hospitals or clinics, more brand name drugs, wellness programs, dental/optical etc. NHIS benefit packages often exclude or limit those.

7. How is hospital choice affected?
   Under NHIS, you are limited to accredited facilities. If your favourite hospital is not approved, you may have a problem. Private plans often include more hospitals/clinics, including private ones, so more choices.

8. Are there hidden costs with NHIS?
   Yes. Even under NHIS, there may be co‑payments, non‑covered services, non‑listed drugs, extra charges for amenities, or if facility is out‑of‑network. Delays and additional travel costs may also add up.

9. What is the speed of service and ease of access like for both options?
   Private insurance usually gives faster service, fewer delays, more comfort. NHIS sometimes has waiting lines, slower authorisation, especially in public hospitals, depending on region, staffing etc.

10. Which is better for families? Students? Low income earners?

    • For low income earners and students: NHIS or a low‑cost private health insurance plan may be suitable.

    • Families who expect maternity, child care, regular health needs: private plans may offer more comfort and wider service.

    • Students: often cost and location matter, so NHIS or state or hybrid solutions may be preferred.

11. How can I check whether a private insurer is good quality?
    Ask: Is it accredited? What is their hospital/clinic network? What do reviews say? What is their customer service like? Are claims paid on time? What are the benefit limits and exclusions?

12. Can private insurance plans change terms without notice?
    They usually have contracts. Terms may change with notice, especially at renewal. Always read policy documents and renewal notices carefully.

13. Does NHIS cover all regions equally?
    No. Some states or rural areas have fewer accredited facilities, less awareness, poorer implementation. Geographic access may be less in remote regions. Private insurance tends to focus on cities.

14. Can private insurance cover services abroad?
    Sometimes premium or elite private plans include or can be upgraded to cover international referrals or treatments abroad; NHIS rarely covers abroad treatment unless very specific exceptional cases—and often with major limitations.

15. What legal protections exist for people under NHIS or private insurance?
    The NHIA Act regulates NHIS now. For private insurers, insurance laws, regulator requirements, consumer protection laws apply. Always ensure insurer is registered/licensed.