Investing in mutual funds, pension schemes, or other managed portfolios is common in Nigeria, Ghana, Kenya, Uganda, and South Africa. Many students and working professionals rely on fund managers to grow their money. But what happens when the fund manager is not performing well? Poor fund manager performance can lead to lower returns, wasted time, and financial frustration. The good news is, there are clear ways to fix this problem. In this article, we will explore step-by-step solutions to improve fund performance and make your money work better for you.
Understanding Fund Manager Performance
What Is a Fund Manager?
A fund manager is a professional responsible for investing money on behalf of investors. They make decisions about which stocks, bonds, or assets to buy or sell, aiming to achieve the fund’s financial goals. Fund managers can work for mutual funds, hedge funds, pension funds, or other investment vehicles.
Why Fund Manager Performance Matters
The performance of your investments depends heavily on the skills and decisions of the fund manager. Poor performance means:
-
Low returns compared to benchmarks
-
Losing money during market growth periods
-
Missed financial goals
Common Causes of Poor Fund Manager Performance
Understanding the reason behind poor performance is key to fixing it. Some common causes include:
-
Lack of Research and Analysis: Fund managers not analyzing markets properly can make wrong decisions.
-
High Turnover of Portfolio: Constant buying and selling can reduce returns due to fees.
-
Poor Risk Management: Ignoring risk and overexposing funds to volatile markets can hurt returns.
-
Overconfidence: Some managers follow trends or gut feelings rather than data.
-
Economic Factors: Inflation, interest rate changes, or political instability in Nigeria, Kenya, Ghana, Uganda, or South Africa can impact performance.
How to Measure Fund Manager Performance
Key Performance Metrics
To fix poor performance, you must measure it accurately. Here are the main metrics:
-
Returns: Compare your fund’s returns to benchmarks like NSE All Share Index (Nigeria) or FTSE/JSE (South Africa).
-
Alpha: Indicates whether the fund is beating the market after adjusting for risk.
-
Beta: Measures the fund’s volatility compared to the market. High beta = high risk.
-
Sharpe Ratio: Shows risk-adjusted returns. A higher ratio means better performance.
-
Expense Ratio: High fees reduce net returns.
Using Benchmarks for Comparison
Always compare your fund to similar funds or market indices. If your fund consistently underperforms, it may be time to take action.
How to Fix Poor Fund Manager Performance
Improving fund performance requires both analysis and action. Here are practical steps:
1. Conduct a Performance Review
-
Check fund returns for the last 1, 3, and 5 years.
-
Compare with benchmark indices and similar funds.
-
Identify if poor performance is temporary or persistent.
2. Analyze the Investment Strategy
-
Review the fund manager’s strategy: growth, value, or balanced approach.
-
Determine if the strategy aligns with your financial goals.
-
Evaluate risk exposure. Are too many investments in high-risk sectors?
3. Communicate With Your Fund Manager
-
Ask questions about fund decisions.
-
Seek explanations for underperformance.
-
Request adjustments in strategy if necessary.
4. Reduce Costs Where Possible
High fees can eat into returns. Consider:
-
Switching to low-cost mutual funds
-
Negotiating fees for long-term investors
-
Avoiding funds with excessive trading costs
5. Diversify Your Investments
-
Avoid putting all your money in one fund.
-
Spread across equities, bonds, real estate, and ETFs.
-
Diversification reduces risk if a single manager underperforms.
6. Set Clear Goals and Expectations
-
Define short-term and long-term financial targets.
-
Ensure the fund manager understands these goals.
-
Monitor performance regularly, at least quarterly.
7. Replace the Fund Manager if Needed
-
If performance does not improve, consider switching to a more competent manager.
-
Look for certified managers with proven track records.
-
Review ratings from Morningstar, Lipper, or local regulators.
8. Use Technology and Analytics
-
Financial analytics tools can track performance in real time.
-
Robo-advisors can supplement human managers for smarter decision-making.
Pros and Cons of Fixing Poor Fund Manager Performance
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Improved returns on investments | May involve switching costs |
| Better risk management | Requires time and effort |
| Enhanced financial planning | Potential short-term volatility |
| Peace of mind | Emotional stress during adjustments |
| Access to professional advice | May involve higher research fees |
Comparison: Fund Manager vs Self-Managed Investment
| Factor | Fund Manager | Self-Managed |
|---|---|---|
| Expertise | Professional knowledge | Dependent on personal skills |
| Time Required | Minimal | High |
| Risk | Shared among fund participants | Entirely your responsibility |
| Cost | Management fees | Broker fees only |
| Performance | Can underperform | Full control but requires skill |
Examples of Fixing Poor Fund Manager Performance
-
Nigeria: An investor in a Lagos-based equity fund noticed returns below the NSE All Share Index for 3 years. After switching to a manager with better market analysis and reducing fees, returns increased by 12% annually.
-
Kenya: A pension fund underperformed due to heavy exposure to a single bank. By diversifying into government bonds and top-performing ETFs, the fund improved stability and long-term growth.
-
Ghana: A young professional invested in a tech-heavy fund. Poor returns led them to request a strategy review. Adjusting the portfolio to include consumer goods and utilities improved returns within 6 months.
Tips for Ongoing Monitoring
-
Quarterly Performance Reviews: Check fund reports every 3 months.
-
Benchmark Comparisons: Track against local indices regularly.
-
Understand Economic Trends: Inflation, interest rates, and political changes affect returns.
-
Review Fund Manager Credentials: Certifications like CFA indicate professionalism.
-
Stay Educated: Learn basic investing principles to ask the right questions.
FAQs About Fund Manager Performance
1. How can I tell if my fund manager is underperforming?
Compare your fund’s returns with similar funds and local benchmarks. Persistent underperformance over 3–5 years is a warning sign.
2. Is it better to switch fund managers or stick with the same one?
If poor performance continues despite communication and strategy adjustments, switching may be wise.
3. Can fees affect fund manager performance?
Yes. High management and trading fees reduce net returns, even if the fund performs well.
4. How often should I review my fund’s performance?
At least quarterly, with annual comprehensive reviews.
5. Are fund managers in Africa qualified to manage my money?
Many are professionally trained and certified. Look for CFA, CPA, or locally recognized financial qualifications.
6. Can poor economic conditions affect performance?
Absolutely. Inflation, currency fluctuations, and political instability can impact returns.
7. Should students invest in managed funds?
Yes, if they seek long-term growth and cannot dedicate time to self-managed investing.
8. What’s the best way to diversify investments?
Spread money across equities, bonds, real estate, ETFs, and money market instruments.
9. Can technology improve fund performance?
Yes. Analytics tools, robo-advisors, and automated trading platforms can help fund managers make informed decisions.
10. What is the risk of leaving a poor-performing fund?
Leaving without proper analysis may lead to missed recovery, but staying too long can reduce returns significantly.
11. How do I communicate effectively with a fund manager?
Ask clear questions about strategy, risk, and fees. Request performance reports and expect transparent answers.
Summary Table: Steps to Fix Poor Fund Manager Performance
| Step | Action | Benefit |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Conduct performance review | Identify underperformance |
| 2 | Analyze investment strategy | Align with goals |
| 3 | Communicate with fund manager | Understand causes of poor performance |
| 4 | Reduce costs | Improve net returns |
| 5 | Diversify investments | Reduce risk |
| 6 | Set clear goals | Guide investment decisions |
| 7 | Replace fund manager | Access better expertise |
| 8 | Use technology | Data-driven decisions |
Conclusion
Poor fund manager performance can be frustrating, but it is not irreversible. By understanding the causes, reviewing performance metrics, communicating with your manager, reducing costs, diversifying investments, and using technology, you can significantly improve returns. Whether you are a student, young professional, or working-class citizen in Nigeria, Ghana, Kenya, Uganda, or South Africa, these steps will help you take control of your investments and achieve financial growth.
Take Action: Start monitoring your fund today, review your strategy, and download our free investment toolkit to boost your fund performance and secure your financial future.