Why Many Africans Avoid Insurance Investments

Insurance is one of the tools people use to protect themselves and invest for the future. Yet in many African countries, a large number of people—students, working class folks, small business owners—either distrust insurance or avoid using insurance-based investment plans. Why does this happen? How can we fix that? And when is insurance a good option?

Let’s begin by clarifying the terms.

---

What Is an Insurance Investment?

An insurance investment refers to insurance products that combine protection (risk coverage) with investment or savings features. These are sometimes called life insurance with investment component, unit-linked insurance plans (ULIPs), endowment policies, or investment-linked insurance.

Here is how it works in simple terms:

• You pay premiums (regular payments) to the insurance company.

• A part of your premium goes toward insurance (protection from death, disability, or other risks).

• Another part is invested by the insurance company in funds (stocks, bonds, assets) on your behalf.

• Over time, your investment portion grows (or loses value depending on performance).

• When the policy matures, or if you die or disable, you (or your beneficiaries) receive benefit: insurance payout + value of investments (or guaranteed minimum + investment returns).

So, insurance investment is a hybrid: protection + investment.

Related Terms: Pure Insurance vs Pure Investment

• Pure insurance means products like term life insurance, car insurance, health insurance. They offer protection only, not growth.

• Pure investment means putting money into stocks, mutual funds, bonds, real estate — no protection component.

• Insurance investments mix both.

Because of that, insurance investment products tend to have higher complexity and cost. And that complexity is part of why many Africans avoid them.

Why Many Africans Avoid Insurance Investments

In many African countries, uptake of these insurance investment products is low. Below are the core reasons and explanations.

Low Trust and Skepticism Toward Insurance Companies

Past Failures and Broken Promises

• Some insurers have failed to deliver promised benefits.

• There are stories of insurers delaying payouts, denying claims, or going bankrupt.

• When people hear such stories in their communities, trust drops.

Lack of Transparency and Hidden Fees

• Some insurance investment policies have many charges: administrative fees, mortality charges, fund management fees, surrender penalties, etc.

• These fees may be unclear to the customer at the start.

• When returns are lower than expected after fees, people feel cheated.

Distance Between Promise and Experience

• The promises are often years or decades ahead. Many people prefer something more immediate.

• Some cannot verify how the insurer invests their funds, or whether what is promised is followed.

Limited Financial Literacy and Awareness

People Don’t Understand How Insurance Investments Work

• Terms like “unit-linked,” “premium allocation,” “fund value” confuse many.

• Many cannot separate the insurance portion from the investment portion.

• They may think all premiums are lost or wasted.

Misconceptions and Myths

• “Insurance is for rich people.”

• “Insurance investment is the same as a savings box.”

• “They will cheat me if I fall sick / die.”

• “Better to invest in business or property rather than insurance.”

These beliefs prevent people from trusting or using insurance investments.

Poor Economic Conditions and Low Disposable Income

Many People Live From Paycheck to Paycheck

• For many working class or students, there is barely enough money for daily needs.

• They cannot commit to regular premiums for insurance-based investments.

Irregular Income

• Many people have irregular or informal income (daily wages, freelance).

• They cannot predict or guarantee paying monthly premiums.

Cultural, Psychological, and Social Barriers

Preference for Tangible Assets

• Many people prefer real things: land, houses, livestock, shops.

• Insurance investment is intangible and often long term.

Skepticism toward “paper promises”

• In communities with weak institutions, people may distrust “paper” contracts.

• They prefer something they can see, touch, control.

Belief in Traditional or Religious Solutions

• Some may rely on spiritual protection, prayers, traditional societies, or community savings before considering insurance.

• Insurance may be seen as a last resort.

Product Design Challenges and Market Issues

High Minimum Premiums, Long Terms

• Many policies require high minimum payment, or long lock-in periods (5, 10, 20 years).

• People fear being stuck for many years with no flexibility.

Illiquid or Poor Exit Options

• If you want to stop the policy early, you may suffer surrender charges or get much less than premium paid.

• The inability to withdraw or exit easily discourages people.

Regulatory Weakness and Policy Risk

• Insurance industries in some countries may have weak oversight, lower enforcement of consumer protection.

• Changes in regulation, taxation, or insurance laws may hurt policyholders.

Poor Distribution, Access, and Agent Practices

• Insurance companies may not have reach in rural or low-income communities.

• Agents sometimes mis-sell, exaggerate returns, hide risks.

• People may not have access to good advice or comparison between products.

Comparative Opportunity Cost

When people consider where to put limited money, they compare options. Many find insurance investments less attractive compared to:

• Small business (shops, trading goods)

• Real estate or land

• Investing in education or skill development

• High-yield informal investments

• Savings or fixed deposits

If those alternatives seem more tangible or easier to understand, insurance loses out.

How Insurance Investment Compares with Other Investments

To understand perceived avoidance, it helps to compare insurance investments vs more familiar investment types.

Comparison Table – Insurance Investment vs Pure Investment Options

Why Some Investors Prefer Pure Options

• Transparency: easier to see what your money is doing.

• Flexibility: easier to sell or change portfolio.

• Lower fees: fewer hidden layers.

• Control: you choose exactly which assets to invest in.

• Simplicity: easier to understand.

But insurance investment still has a role, especially for combining protection with growth. The key is to understand when and how.

How to Make Insurance Investment More Attractive (What Needs to Change)

Here are things that insurers, governments, and consumers can do to reduce barriers and improve uptake.

Improving Trust and Transparency

• Insurance companies must show clear breakdowns: how much goes to protection, how much to investment.

• Publish historical fund performance, fees, deduction policies in simple forms.

• Ensure prompt, fair claims experience—building positive reputation.

Simplify Products and Lower Barriers to Entry

• Design policies with small minimum premiums.

• Offer shorter lock-in periods or flexible premium payment options.

• Offer partial withdrawal or liquidity features without heavy penalties.

Consumer Education and Awareness Campaigns

• Teach what insurance investment means, how returns are generated, risks involved, how to read policy documents.

• Use radio, TV, online platforms in local languages.

• Deliver financial literacy in schools, workplaces.

Regulatory and Policy Reforms

• Government regulation to ensure consumer protection, force clarity in product disclosures.

• Subsidies, tax incentives to encourage insurance investment uptake.

• Enforcement against mis-selling, fraud, overcharging agents.

Better Distribution Channels and Agent Training

• Use digital distribution — mobile apps, online platforms — to expand reach.

• Train agents to advise honestly, not just sell commission products.

• Provide comparison platforms for consumers to compare insurance investment products.

Integrating Insurance Investments with Other Services

• Bundling insurance investment with microfinance, mobile money, cooperative societies.

• Partner with banks, fintechs to ease premium collection and participation.

• Use employer‑based schemes (deduct from salary) to ensure regular contributions.

Step‑by‑Step Guide: How an Individual Can Evaluate an Insurance Investment

For a student or worker considering an insurance investment, here is a stepwise guide:

Step 1 – Understand Your Needs: Protection vs Investment

Decide what proportion of your priority is protection (life, disability) and how much is growth. If your primary need is protection, a pure insurance plan might suffice; if growth is priority, choose better investment components.

Step 2 – Compare Different Products

Compare:

• Premiums (amount, frequency)

• Duration / lock-in period

• Investment fund options (aggressive, conservative)

• Historical fund performance

• Guarantees (if any)

• Fees and charges (administrative, mortality, fund management)

• Surrender value, withdrawal terms

• Death / disability benefits

Step 3 – Calculate Expected Returns Net of Fees

Don’t look at gross returns. Subtract all fees and projected costs. Use real rate of return (after inflation). Ask for net projections. Check multiple scenarios: base case, low case, high case.

Step 4 – Assess Insurance Company Strength and Reputation

• Check company’s financial ratings, creditworthiness, solvency.

• How long has it operated?

• Claims history and customer feedback.

• Regulatory oversight in that country.

Step 5 – Check Liquidity, Exit Options, and Flexibility

• Can you withdraw money if needed?

• How much do you lose on surrender?

• If you miss premiums, what happens?

• Does it allow premium holidays or adjustments?

Step 6 – Evaluate Risk and Safeguards

• What are the investment risks (market risk, asset allocation)?

• Is there a guaranteed floor or minimum?

• Are funds diversified (equities, bonds, money markets)?

• Is there protection against inflation (real returns)?

Step 7 – Run Scenarios and Sensitivity Analysis

• What if returns are lower by 20 %?

• What if inflation is high?

• What if you stop paying premiums for a few years?

• What if you live less than expected?

Step 8 – Decide and Monitor

• After comparing, choose the policy that gives you acceptable trade-off.

• Monitor performance regularly (yearly).

• If performance is poor or costs too high, consider switching to another product (if allowed).

Pros and Cons of Insurance Investment for Africans

Understanding both sides helps make a good decision.

Pros (Why Insurance Investment Can Be Useful)

1. Combined protection + investment
   You get life cover, disability cover, plus growth of invested funds.

2. Forced savings discipline
   Premiums make you save regularly. You are less likely to skip contributions.

3. Tax incentives (in some countries)
   Many countries offer tax deductions or exemptions on insurance investments.

4. Guaranteed minimum benefits (in some plans)
   Some policies offer a guaranteed floor even if investments perform poorly.

5. Long term growth with compounding
   Over years, investment components may grow significantly.

6. Estate planning, inheritance
   Insurance parts ensure beneficiaries get benefits; investment parts add asset value.

7. Diversification of one’s portfolio
   Insurance investment can diversify beyond business, real estate, or stocks.

Cons (Why Many Avoid it)

1. High fees and hidden costs
   Multiple layers of cost eat into returns.

2. Complexity and low transparency
   Hard to understand how premiums are split, unclear fund management.

3. Illiquidity and poor exit options
   Surrender charges and penalties deter early withdrawal.

4. Risk of underperformance
   Investments may yield lower returns than projected or may lose money during downturns.

5. Long duration, slow acquisition of value
   It may take many years before you see meaningful value; early years often go mostly to costs.

6. Regulatory, insurer risk
   If the insurer fails or regulation changes, you may suffer.

7. Opportunity cost
   Money locked in insurance could be invested elsewhere more profitably (if you have other channels).

Real Examples from Nigeria, Kenya, and South Africa

Here are hypothetical but realistic stories to illustrate how insurance investments are viewed and what challenges people face.

Nigeria – Young Professional Avoids Life‑Investment Plans

Chinedu is a 30-year-old engineer in Lagos. He was offered a life insurance plan that combines investment. The agent promised “assured returns and protection.” But after reading the policy and asking neighbors, Chinedu saw:

• The premium was relatively high.

• High early surrender penalties.

• The insurer had negative reviews about delayed claims.

• He already preferred investing in a side business with quicker returns.

So Chinedu avoided it, and instead put his extra money into a small digital service business and a fixed deposit.

Kenya – Mid‑Level Officer Struggles with Premiums

Aisha is a government worker in Nairobi. She was sold a 15-year endowment policy that included life cover. She paid premiums for 3 years, but missed two payments due to financial stress. She tried to resume, but found:

• The policy had penalty for missed payments.

• She could not withdraw money easily.

• When she asked for projected returns, she saw net return was weak after fees.

She lost confidence and considered cancelling, but the surrender value was small. She now relies more on pension plans and other investments.

South Africa – Business Owner Weighs Unit-Linked Plans

Lerato is a small business owner in Pretoria. She was offered a unit-linked insurance plan by an insurer tied to equity funds. She liked that she had life cover plus investment exposure. She checked:

• The insurer’s financial strength and ratings.

• Past performance of the funds.

• Fees and management charges.

• Flexibility: ability to switch fund allocations.

She decided to invest a portion of her savings in the plan, while keeping some funds in pure equities and real estate so she has diversification and liquidity.

These examples show common barriers and how careful evaluation matters.

Summary Table Before Conclusion

Here is a compact summary of reasons, barriers, and solutions for insurance investment uptake in Africa:

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are common questions people ask about insurance investments, explained simply.

1: Is insurance investment safe?

Not entirely safe. Like all investments, insurance investment faces risks (market risk, fees, insurer risk). But safety depends on the insurer’s strength, regulatory oversight, and how well the product is designed.

2: Can I get my money back early?

Usually yes, but with restrictions. Many policies enforce a surrender value or penalty if you withdraw early. You might get much less than what you paid early on.

3: Are insurance investments better than business investments?

They serve different purposes. Insurance investment gives you both protection and growth. Business investment may yield higher returns but comes with operational risk and no protection. Many people use both for balance.

4: Do I need insurance investment if I already have life insurance?

Yes, if your goal is also growth of capital. Pure life insurance gives protection alone. Insurance investment gives protection and chance for returns. But make sure you understand both products carefully.

5: What fees should I look out for?

• Administrative / management fees

• Mortality / risk charges

• Fund management / asset management fees

• Commission to agents

• Surrender / exit charges

• Switching fees

Always ask the company to show a fee breakdown.

6: How do I choose a good insurer?

• Check financial strength, ratings, solvency, reputation

• Check claims history and customer reviews

• Regulatory license and oversight in your country

• Transparency of fund performance and charges

• Good customer service and complaint resolution

7: What is a unit‑linked insurance plan (ULIP)?

A ULIP is an insurance investment product where part of your premium is invested in a fund, and the insurance component gives life or risk coverage. You can often choose which funds (equity, bond, cash) to allocate into.

8: What happens if I miss premium payments?

Different policies handle this differently. Some allow grace periods. Some pause the policy, reduce benefits, or impose fees. If you miss many payments, the policy may lapse and you lose benefits or earlier premiums.

9: Should I use insurance investment for retirement / long-term goals?

Yes, it can be helpful for long-term goals like retirement, education, legacy, because of the combination of protection and growth. But you must choose a policy with good projections, suitable premium term, and manageable risk.

10: Can insurance investments beat inflation?

It depends. If the fund investments’ returns exceed inflation, then yes. But fees, poor performance, or currency devaluation could erode real returns. Always look at real return (after inflation).

11: How often should I review my insurance investment?

At least once a year. Review fund performance, costs, compare to other options, check if the insurer is still strong. Consider switching or adjusting if allowed.

12: Is it okay to combine insurance investment with other investments?

Yes, combining insurance investment with pure investments (stocks, real estate, business) is often wise to diversify and achieve liquidity, protection, and growth goals.

Conclusion

Insurance investment can be a valuable tool—it provides protection plus potential growth. But many Africans avoid it due to trust issues, complexity, high fees, low income, poor liquidity, and better alternatives.

To overcome these barriers:

1. Insurance companies must become more transparent, trustworthy, and consumer‑oriented.

2. Regulators must enforce protections, require disclosure, and reward good actors.

3. Educating citizens—students, workers—on how insurance investments work is key.

4. Individuals must evaluate carefully if and when an insurance investment is right: checking fees, liquidity, insurer strength, and matching it to their goals.

5. Combining insurance investments with other investments helps balance protection and flexibility.

For many working people and students in Nigeria, Kenya, South Africa, insurance investment should not be ignored—but it must be approached wisely. With proper knowledge, careful selection, and a mix of investment strategies, insurance investment can be part of a stronger financial future.